World Bank Spring Meeting 2026 Nordic-Baltic CSO Letter
Dear Ms. Rawet
We, the Nordic-Baltic civil society constituency working for human rights, the eradication of poverty, climate justice as well as fair distribution of power and resources, thank you for the opportunity to comment on the Nordic-Baltic Constituency’s work within the World Bank and would like to take the opportunity to raise some issues of concern ahead of the 2026 Spring Meetings.
Social Protection: Review of the Low-Income Debt Sustainability Framework (LIC-DSF)
We raised the LIC-DSF review in our latest letter, and the process is now approaching a decisive phase. Following a virtual off-the-record roundtable in December where IMF and World Bank staff informed about the review process, the Global Coalition for Social Protection Floors developed a written input which has been shared with the staff. It includes concrete suggestions for how LIC-DSF can support governments in assuming their responsibility to maintain and expand social protection and other social spending. In summary:
- The economic model used to devise the baseline scenario should incorporate an evidence-based fiscal multiplier for social protection spending
- The stress tests (shocks) must assume social protection spending increases commensurate with each shock.
- Where fiscal consolidation is a feature of the baseline, social spending (education, health, social protection) should be “ringfenced” obligations.
- Arrears to civil servants and pensioners should be considered government repayment obligations of higher priority than arrears to creditors.
- IMF and Bank staff must carry out deeper and broader consultations with civil society to assess the political feasibility of its baseline scenario.
Do you agree with these suggestions? Are you willing to promote them, or any particular of them, in the upcoming board discussions about LIC-DSF?
Cost of introducing universal programmes
As mentioned in our previous letter, the perception that universal social security benefits are too costly to implement in low- and middle-income countries is hampering the development of social protection. A recent report by ILO sadly reinforces that perception, suggesting that it would require 19.8 per cent of GDP for low-income countries to implement universal social security. In our previous letter we flagged the publication of a new report by Development Pathways and Act Church of Sweden. The report Beyond the unaffordability myth: A pragmatic roadmap to universal social security, published in December, shows that the financing gap for introducing basic tax-finances benefits (old age pension, child benefit, disability benefit and maternity benefit) in LIC is less than 3 percent of GDP. As these benefits are introduced over a long period of time, the annual cost increase is much smaller.
A key methodological feature concerns how the levels of benefits are decided. The report is based on a pragmatic choice: the median level of existing benefit levels in other countries (expressed as percentage of GDP per capita) is used as the point of reference.
The report is accompanied by an online costing tool that can be used by anyone, where parameters such as number of years for implementation and number and level of benefits can be changed. The report was ranked 15 in the Ugo Gentilini’s (the World Bank’s leading expert on social protection) list of top 100 social protection resources in 2025.
Do you think that the report, and the methodology that it is based on, is useful for discussions in the World Bank on the feasibility of introducing universal social benefits?
Universal and poverty-targeted social protection
As has been argued in several earlier letters, there are several reasons for why the World Bank’s promotion of poverty-targeted social protection is highly problematic. In late 2025, Bloomsbury Academic the former DFID staff Matthew Greenslade published the book Beyond the World Bank: The Fight for Universal Social Protection in the Global South (open access, sponsored by Act Church of Sweden). The book provides a comprehensive critique of poverty targeting, proxy means testing etc, and several concrete examples of how the World Bank has been acting in different country contexts. But it is also a story about real people - in particular Stephen Kidd at Development Pathways, with whom Act Church of Sweden has collaborated with for several years - but also of a number of people in the Global South.
We believe that the publication of the book creates momentum for the Nordic-Baltic constituency to question the World Bank’s current approach. We have two concrete suggestions that we would like to discuss with you.
- That the European EDs make a joint initiative, based on the common European values and experiences of predominately universal social protection systems. A first step would be to put universal social protection on the agenda for one of the “retreats”.
- That the Nordic-Baltic constituency, perhaps together with another constituency, initiates a study by the Independent Evaluation Group (IEG). The focus of such a study has to be discussed and carefully framed, of course. The World Bank’s high level commitment to universal social protection through gradual expansion could be one entry point. The persistent high exclusion errors could be another.
Are any of these suggestions feasible, and if so, what would be the next step?
Finally, we recently received information from Helpage International that “Kenya's Social Protection Act reverts the country's trailblazing universal social protection back to a poverty-targeted one, which would be a real step-back for universal social protection in Kenya and in the region, and a disaster for older people”. If implemented, this aspect of the Act could mean that hundreds of thousands of elderly people would no longer be receiving pensions. We know that the World Bank has discouraged the Kenyan government from implementing the universal pension before (it is described in the book by Matthew Greenslade and in this blog). We also know that the introduction of a social registry which may be used to select beneficiaries for a number of social programs, including pensions – based on proxy means testing (PMT) – has been a condition in policy based loans to Kenya.
We would now like to understand what role the World Bank is playing in the current policy development in the country. In particular, civil society organisations request that the World Bank share details of the PMT design (which survey, indicators and weights are used?) and what assessments are made to estimate targeting errors. Transparent sharing of this information will increase the possibility for national CSOs to hold the Bank and government accountable.
Responsible sovereign lending & borrowing
At the fourth Financing for Development Conference in Sevilla 2026 the world's nations committed to advance the agenda of developing a global consensus on systems for ensuring responsible sovereign lending and borrowing. At this year's Financing for Development Forum in New York a new working group with this aim will be launched as a collaboration between UNDESA, the World Bank and the IMF.
How will the Nordic Baltic EDs office be involved in advancing this important work in the time to come? And how will the Nordic Baltic constituency advance implementation of principles on responsible sovereign lending and borrowing, and the need for greater debt transparency, within the fund & the bank?
Gender
The World Bank’s refresh of its Fragility, Conflict and Violence (FCV) Strategy comes amid intensifying, protracted crises - violent conflict and climate emergency - that disproportionately affect women, girls, and marginalised groups. These impacts are made worse by structural inequalities and a global backlash against gender equality and human rights.
The World Bank has previously demonstrated leadership on gender (during COVID‑19, through IDA20/21, and in the 2024-30 Gender Strategy). We are now deeply concerned that gender is not fully integrated in the current FCV refresh draft. We urge the Nordic–Baltic Constituency to champion a course correction so the FCV strategy protects and accelerates gender equality in FCV contexts.
Priority 1: Put gender and intersectionality at the core of the FCV Strategy
- Embed gender analysis throughout: Require conflict‑responsive, intersectional gender analysis at strategy level (not only country add‑ons).
- Align with the Women, Peace and Security (WPS) Agenda: Integrate gender‑responsive conflict analysis; provide for participation, protection, recovery, and reconstruction measures that reflect WPS commitments.
- Center women’s rights organisations (WROs): Ensure safe, equal, and meaningful participation of women’s rights organisations in decisions that affect them, across strategy design, implementation, and review.
- Address intersectional risks: Incorporate intersecting dimensions (e.g., ethnicity, indigeneity, disability, class, geography) in risk assessment, design, targeting, and monitoring, including context‑specific GBV risk analysis.
Priority 2: Protect and expand women’s economic rights and decent work in FCV and recovery
- Go beyond “jobs” to “decent work”: Anchor interventions in the ILO definition of decent work and expand beyond private sector jobs to include public sector opportunities with social protection.
- Invest in the care economy: Recognise and reduce unpaid care burdens that surge in crises; budget for childcare, social care, and community services; use gender‑responsive budgeting and participatory budgeting with women’s representation.
- Design recovery for inclusion: Ensure post‑conflict reconstruction creates dignified opportunities for women and girls (vocational and financial literacy training; access to assets and finance; safe mobility). Avoid rebuilding around male‑dominated sectors alone.
- Support green and just transitions: Prioritise women’s access to low‑carbon, high‑care sectors.
- Address displacement realities: Ensure displaced women’s income generation is safe, dignified, and protected from exploitation and abuse.
- Require a dedicated pillar on women’s economic rights and decent work, including care economy investments and targeted measures in displacement and recovery contexts.
- Prioritise family law reform: As discriminatory family laws remain a major barrier to women’s human rights, access to justice, and economic opportunities. Evidence shows that egalitarian family law is one of the strongest drivers of women’s economic empowerment, accelerating gender equality, strengthening families and communities, and helping to dismantle harmful social norms.
Priority 3: Ensure protection and participation in line with WPS, including financing for GBV and WROs
- Resource protection and GBV response: Guarantee survivor‑centered GBV prevention and response as essential services in FCV operations.
- Finance women’s participation: Fund WROs for their expertise, time, and access; treat their participation as a core program cost and peace multiplier.
Cross‑cutting
- Country Partnership Frameworks (CPFs): Make CPFs conflict‑responsive and gender‑responsive, with GBV risk assessment and mitigation baked into design.
- Indicators and disaggregation: Require gender‑responsive, intersectional indicators (sex, age, disability, ethnicity, rural/urban) with baselines and targets; track mid‑term and at end‑of‑cycle with public reporting.
- Budget and staffing: Increase funding for gender expertise and M&E; recruit/retain staff with FCV, gender and GBV competencies; systematically engage external experts (including women’s rights activists) for capacity building.
- Formalise consultations: Establish regular, formal channels for CSO incl WRO input at global and country levels; ensure feedback loops and accountability to these stakeholders.
- Climate-conflict-gender nexus: Integrate climate justice and resilience measures recognising that climate stress exacerbates fragility and GBV.
Question to the N-B Constituency:
How can you make sure that the FCV refresh explicitly integrates gender and intersectionality across strategy text?
Can you call for publication of consultation findings with a management response clarifying how inputs influenced the draft.
Debt Justice Norway
The Kvinna till Kvinna Foundation
Act Church of Sweden